In the field of mining and stone processing, choosing the right crushing equipment is crucial to production efficiency and operating costs. Faced with the task of crushing high-hardness rocks, jaw crushers and cone crushers are the two most common choices. This article will comprehensively analyze the performance characteristics, applicable scenarios and economic benefits of these two types of equipment to help you make a wise selection decision.
Special challenges of hard rock crushing
Hard rocks (such as granite, basalt, quartzite, etc.) usually have the following characteristics:
• High Mohs hardness (above level 6)
• High compressive strength (>150MPa)
• High silicon content and strong abrasiveness
• High requirements for particle shape after crushing
These characteristics pose a severe test to the crushing equipment, requiring the equipment to have:
✔ Strong crushing force
✔ Excellent wear resistance
✔ Stable discharge particle size control
✔ Low maintenance cost
1. Jaw crusher: a strong choice for primary crushing of hard rocks
Working principle and structural characteristics
The jaw crusher adopts the principle of "extrusion crushing" and realizes material crushing through the periodic engagement of the moving jaw plate and the fixed jaw plate. Its core advantages are:
• Large crushing ratio: usually up to 6-8, suitable for primary crushing of large hard rocks
• Simple structure: easy maintenance, low failure rate
• Strong adaptability: can handle various hardness materials, including raw materials with high mud content
• Large feed inlet: can handle raw materials up to 1500mm
Hard rock crushing performance
Advantages:
• High crushing efficiency: single machine processing capacity can reach 1000t/h
• Long life of wear-resistant parts: using high manganese steel jaw plate, the service life can reach 6-12 months under hard rock conditions
• Flexible discharge adjustment: quickly change product particle size by adjusting the discharge port
Limitations:
• Poor product particle size uniformity
• Large operating vibration, high foundation requirements
• The fine crushing effect is not as good as the cone crusher
Industry data: In the granite crushing production line, the jaw crusher as the primary crushing equipment can reduce the subsequent equipment load by more than 30%
2. Cone crusher: ideal solution for fine crushing in hard rock
Working principle and technological evolution
Cone crusher adopts the principle of "laminated crushing" to achieve material crushing through continuous squeezing between the moving cone and the fixed cone. Modern hydraulic cone crusher has:
• Multi-chamber design: adapt to the needs of different crushing stages
• Hydraulic adjustment: more convenient and accurate adjustment of the discharge port
• Intelligent control system: realize load protection and automatic adjustment
Hard rock crushing performance
Outstanding advantages:
• Excellent product shape: high cubic content, less needle-like
• Uniform particle size: accurate control of closed-side discharge port
• Smooth operation: small vibration and low noise
Strong wear resistance: key components are made of special alloys, and the service life can reach more than 2000 hours under hard rock conditions
Disadvantages:
• High initial investment cost
• Sensitive to mud content, prone to blockage
• Complex structure, high maintenance technology requirements
Key performance comparison analysis
| Indicators |
Jaw crusher |
Cone Crusher |
| Applicable stage |
Primary crushing |
Medium and fine crushing |
| Maximum feed particle size |
1500mm |
300mm |
| Product particle size |
Less uniform |
Uniform |
| Processing capacity (t/h) |
50-1000 |
50-2000 |
| Power consumption (kWh/t) |
0.5-1.2 |
0.8-1.5 |
| Replacement cycle of wear parts |
6-12 months |
2000-3000 hours |
| Equipment basic requirements |
High |
General |
| Price range (10,000 yuan) |
15-200 |
50-500 |
Equipment adaptability for different hard rock types
Granite crushing
Advantages of jaw crusher: High efficiency in processing large pieces of raw ore, particle size of 150-300mm after primary crushing
Advantages of cone crusher: Secondary crushing can obtain high-quality aggregates, with needle-like content <10%
Basalt crushing
Recommended combination: jaw crusher + cone crusher combined operation
Special consideration: Basalt is highly abrasive, and reinforced wear-resistant parts are required
Quartzite crushing
Cone crusher is better: There is a special cavity design for high-silicon materials
Key points: A dust removal system is required to control the harm of silica dust
For hard rock crushing, the best solution is usually a combination of jaw crusher and cone crusher
• Primary crushing stage: Use a jaw crusher with a large feed inlet to process the raw ore
• Medium and fine crushing stage: Configure a cone crusher to optimize the product particle shape
If the budget or site is limited, you must select one:
• Choose a jaw crusher if: the raw material size is large, the product requirements are not high, and the investment budget is limited
• Choose a cone crusher if: you pursue high-quality aggregates, process medium-sized raw materials, and attach importance to long-term operating benefits
The final decision should be based on specific material characteristics, product requirements and investment return analysis. It is recommended to consult a professional crushing equipment supplier for personalized solution design.
Perfect after-sales service
Baichy Heavy Industry provides professional on-site guidance for installation, training of workers, and other services to ensure that customers can use the equipment smoothly.
The company has a complete after-sales service system, which can provide customers with timely technical support and equipment maintenance services to ensure the long-term stable operation of the equipment.
To prevent the rights and interests of customers from being infringed, Baichy Heavy Industry reminds customers: please contact our customer service staff through the official website of Baichy Heavy Industry , or add WhatsApp: 15093222637 ; or send an email to: [email protected] , we will get in touch with you as soon as possible and provide you with the most professional service in the industry.
Further reading:
